Arena Club

What Arena Club says

• The offer"The Arena Club Offer you receive is 100% of the estimated value minus a 10% app fee." It's "calculated as a percentage of the item's estimated value — not as a percentage of what you paid for the pack." Offer price What is the Offer
• Slab SafeA 10% premium at checkout guarantees "at least 80% of the Slab Pack price (minus the premium) or 90% of the estimated value of the card you received, whichever is greater". Arena Club's example: $100 pack, $65 card, offer $80 instead of $58.50. Slab Safe
• Who sets the valueArena Club: "We try to take the average price of recent sales, but when data is sparse, we'll use a single recent comp." Comping
• The windowNot stated on Arena Club's help pages. Slab Safe offers "expire after a set period", shown with the offer. Slab Safe window
• Where the money goesYour Arena Club Wallet; rip again or withdraw (see question 5). Cards sold back "could go back into Arena Club's inventory". What is the Offer Same card again
• Other exitsKeep the slab in your Showroom, list or trade it on the marketplace, or retrieve it. Slab Packs

What players say

• Many players call the offers fair or strong."That's a really generous offer, I would sell back." r/ArenaClub, 25 Aug "Arena clubs offers are usually very reasonable." App Store, 30 Sep

• Many players say offers can come in under recent comps."Arena Club Value is $575 (Offer $517). CL has it at $780" r/ArenaClub, 6 Oct

• Several players like Slab Safe as a floor."just by adding a few dollars you get insurance on it also!!" App Store, 9 Oct

What Arena Club says

• Hit tiersEach pack splits into Grail, Chase and Lineup cards. On the tier packs (Bronze to Crown Jewel), a Chase or Grail is 1.7% to 2.6% of pulls and a Lineup card about 98%. Bronze Baseball ($25): Grail 0.03%, Chase 2.08%, Lineup 98%. CPZ pack list
• How packs are builtA weighted Fisher-Yates shuffle uses "each slab's predefined hit-rate"; IOActive audited it and found "no viable pathway for anyone, inside or outside Arena Club, to bias or reorder Slab Pack contents". Randomness
• What's in the pool"We are fully transparent about the cards available in each series at any time, so you can review the full list of potential cards before purchasing." Same card again
• Average value and chance to beat the pack pricenot published on the pages we read, and not in our /stats feed.

What players say

• Most players say pulls land under the pack price.It's the top complaint in App Store reviews. "I've spent at least $1000, on packs priced $25-$100. I still haven't even got a card worth valued more than the pack." App Store, 21 Oct

• Several players report pulling the same card twice."Got the same Jalen Hurts from the yahoo fantasy pack twice." App Store, 18 Oct Arena Club says sold-back cards can return to the pool.

• A few players say the floor got lower on cheaper packs."Floor has gotten considerably worse. Especially on the lower end packs" r/ArenaClub, 5 Oct

What Arena Club says

• Arena Club's termsRetrieval is "$1 per card", plus shipping (by size, destination and service) and insurance (by declared value). Over $1,000 declared value ships 2-day. Retrieval cost
• Carriers and timingFedEx in the US (UPS as backup), FedEx or DHL abroad. Retrievals "may take up to one week to process and ship out". Carriers Timing
• Outside the USRetrievals go to countries FedEx or DHL serve, except sanctioned or restricted ones; Bahrain, Israel, Kuwait, Qatar and the UAE have temporary restrictions. The recipient pays all duties and taxes. Countries Duties

What players say

• Many players say retrieval adds up on a low pull, and most of all abroad."I have to pay $1 retrieval fee $1 ins fee $10.99 shipping and $9 tax. Is this normal" r/ArenaClub, 18 Aug "They tried charging me $89 delivery to deliver to the UK" Trustpilot, 12 Jul

• A few players say US shipping stays low."The shipping is max $15 in the US, $1 per card" r/ArenaClub, 16 Sep

Ratings as shown in Oct 2026

What Arena Club says

• Who runs itArenaClub.com, Inc. Slab Packs
• The shuffleIndependently audited by IOActive, a US cybersecurity firm. Randomness
• RatingsApp Store 4.5 from 7.1K ratings. Google Play 4.2 from 2.18K reviews, 100K+ downloads. Trustpilot 1.7 from 38 reviews. App Store Google Play Trustpilot

What players say

• Several players single out the marketplace and trading."The trading feature is hands down the best was to grow a card collection." App Store, 15 Aug

What Arena Club says

• Paying in"Apple Pay, Google Pay, Stripe Link, all major credit cards, and Crypto." Purchases must use your own credit or debit card. Payments Eligibility
• Cashing outWallet funds move to a Stripe Connect account, then to your bank or debit card; "Withdrawals to your bank or debit card typically take 1-3 business days". Stripe's minimum is $1. Withdraw Timing
• Where it worksPayouts go to bank accounts in 20 countries, including the US, Canada, Australia, Japan and much of Western Europe. Elsewhere you can buy, but "seller accounts and payouts are not available". Seller countries
• ID check (KYC)Stripe sets up the payout account; Arena Club's pages don't describe a separate ID check. Withdraw

What players say

• Many players report withdrawals that were slow or didn't arrive."Arena Club withdrawals marked “Completed” but never received — anyone else experiencing this?" r/ArenaClub, 18 Sep

• Several players say withdrawals go through without trouble."I've withdrawn probably close to 100 times now and have never had a single issue." r/ArenaClub, 23 Oct

What Arena Club says

• VIPThree tiers, Enthusiast, Hobbyist and Curator, set by what you collect over a rolling 90 days. Perks include lower costs, faster shipping and an account manager. Thresholds are not published. VIP
• TokensPack Protect (a guaranteed minimum offer, "for example 80%, 90%, or 100%" of the pack price), Pack Discount and Free Slab Safe. Tokens
• Arena CashA promo reward: "You can't buy it, and it can't be withdrawn, transferred, or converted to cash." Arena Cash
• Referrals"We don't currently have a referral program in place." Referrals

What players say

• A few players rate the loyalty perks above other sites."Arena Club has better rewards for loyalty and more ideal buyback options" X, 25 Sep

• Several players say a promo code didn't apply as expected."the promo code for my fist pack rip was deemed as used because of the marketplace purchase" X, 22 Oct

What Arena Club says

• How it worksQuestions go to [email protected]; VIP members get "direct human support" through an account manager. Withdraw VIP

What players say

• Several players say replies take days."customer service takes days to reply just to tell me to try using a browser instead of the app" App Store, 23 Oct